fbpx

10 Best Herbs to Grow in New York (2021 Guide)

What are the best herbs to grow in New York?

Finding the best herbs to grow in New York was not as easy as I thought. Some require extensive care, others are prone to pests, and lots are just not simple & quick enough to grow.

That’s why I created a list of the 10 Best Herbs to Grow in New York!

This ultimate guide will give you the best herbs to grow, why you should grow them, and even how to grow them.


Read THIS Before Growing Herbs in New York

Knowing what hardiness zone New York is in is critical to understanding the best herbs that can be grown.

It can be the difference between your herb garden thriving and providing a bountiful yield or producing nothing.

New York is mostly considered Hardiness Zone 5, while some of the lower-level regions are Hardiness Zone 6.

hardiness zone map


10 Best Herbs to Grow in New York

#1. Basil

basil

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: Sweet, Genovese, Thai, Purple

Why Grow Basil in New York?

basil

Thrives in Heat:

  • As the summers get warmer basil continues to get grow and become more flavorful. Look no further for a low-maintenance herb.

Low-Maintenance:

  • Basil may be the easiest herbs to grow. You do not need to fertilize it, only need to water it once to twice a week, and it can be planted in any soil.

Perfect for ANY Garden:

  • Basil is perfect for urban gardening, window boxes, garden containers, and areas of little space. It is also great in traditional gardens, raised garden beds, and even indoors.

Harvested All Summer:

  • Basil can be harvested all summer. The more you harvest basil the more it will grow.

THESE Could Harm Your Basil

Disease:

  • Basil is one of the most disease-prone herbs. Expect blight, fungus, and rot to affect your plant in the later summer months.

Frost:

  • If the weather drops below 35 degrees Fahrenheit expect your basil to not grow, become stunted, and die. This means you should grow your herb well after the last frost and harvest before the first frost of the fall.

Additional Resources

Learn How To Grow Basil HERE


#2. Oregano

common oregano

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: Italian, Common, Greek, Cuban

Why Grow Oregano in New York?

Greek Oregano

Cold Hardy:

  • Oregano is the hardiest herb when it comes to cold in New York. Unlike any other herb on this list, Oregano can be grown throughout the entire year.

Ornamental:

  • Oregano can also be considered an ornamental plant that is perfect for edges, garden containers, and traditional gardens. This means it can add color, features, and beauty to any type of yard.

Perennial:

  • One of the greatest benefits of growing oregano is that it is a perennial plant. This means you plant it once and you can enjoy it every year!

THESE Could Harm Your Oregano

Invasive

  • Herbs are rarely invasive plants. But herbs can be. If you don’t prune your oregano it can quickly take over a garden and hurt your other plants.

Extreme Heat

  • Unlike other herbs, extreme heat won’t kill your herbs. However, it will hurt its flavor and longevity of its use.

Additional Resources

Learn How To Grow Oregano HERE


#3. Mint

peppermint plant

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: Peppermint, Spearmint, Chocolate

Why Grow Mint in New York?

apple mint

Thrives in Cold:

  • While some herbs are cold-hardy, Mint thrive in New York’s cold weather. If you want the tastiest peas you should grow them in winter and early spring.

Low Maintenance:

  • Mint is the easiest herb to grow. You do not need to fertilize it, barely need to water it, it can be planted in any soil, and you never have to prune it!

Perfect in Containers:

  • The best spot to plant mint is in gardening containers. This is because you can grow them anywhere, such as your house, gardening pot, and even a window box.

THESE Could Harm Your Mint

Invasive:

  • Mint is incredibly invasive. This means it will spread among your garden and potentially kill your other plants within a year. Because of this most gardeners will become frustrated and naturally destroy their mint.

Additional Resources

Learn How to Grow Mint HERE


#4. Sage

sage

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: Garden, Pineapple, Purple, Golden

Why Grow Sage in New York?

growing sage outdoors

Thrives in the heat:

  • As the summers get warmer sage continues to get bigger and more plentiful. Look no further for a low-maintenance herb.

Repels Mosquitoes:

  • Sage is one of the best herbs to grow in your garden to repel mosquitoes and other insects. You can leave it in your garden, burn it, or even rub it on you to repel bugs.

Perfect in All Types of Garden:

  • Some herbs only do well in the ground. Not sage. You can grow them in containers, window boxes, raised garden beds, and even in poor soil.

THESE Could Harm Your Sage

Diseases:

  • Sage is also one of the most disease-prone herbs, especially non-garden variants. Expect your herb to most vulnerable during spring or summer (even if you properly care for them).

Additional Resources

Learn How to Grow Sage HERE


#5. Thyme

common thyme

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: Common, Lemon, Woolly

Why Grow Thyme in New York?

lemon thyme

Thrives in the heat & cold:

  • Thyme is one of the most versatile herbs. Some varieties can be grown in cold weather, some can be grown in warmer weather, and some are perfect to be grown in both types of weather.

Provides All-Summer Harvest:

  • Tyme is one of the few herbs that you will be harvest from as early as spring to late fall. This means you will be able to enjoy or store it all year long.

Easy to Grow:

  • Thyme is incredibly easy to grow. All you do it plant it, water it, and continue watering throughout the summer. That’s it!

THESE Could Harm Your Thyme

Birds, Squirrels, Rabbits, & Chipmunks:

  • These pests will generally not harm your actual thyme. What they will do though is immediately eat soft thyme leaves if you do not protect them with netting or rodent spray.

Insects:

  • Thyme is one of the few herbs that insects will destroy. Insects can quickly destroy your thyme leaves before flowers grow and can destroy the herb itself if not properly cared for.

Additional Resources

Learn How to Grow Thyme HERE


#6. Rosemary

caring for rosemary

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: Creeping, Tuscan, Arp

Why Grow Rosemary in New York?

creeping rosemary

Thrives in the heat & cold:

  • Rosemary is another hardy herb. Some varieties can be grown in cold weather and some can be grown in warmer weather.

Lots & Lots of Harvest:

  • Rosemary is one of the few herbs that you can harvest from late spring to late fall. This means you will be able to enjoy it all year long.

Amazing Cross-Pollinator:

  • Rosemary is a herb that works great to help to cross-pollinate other herbs. Plant rosemary next to beans, cabbage, and peppers for an even larger harvest.

THESE Could Harm Your Rosemary

Beetles:

  • Beetles are ferocious. While they typically eat leaves of trees they can also destroy rosemary plants. To help prevent this I recommend using netting.

Droughts:

  • Drought is one of the biggest threats to growing rosemary. Rosemary plants need a consistent amount of water to thrive and produce a large harvest.

Additional Resources

Learn How to Grow Rosemary HERE


#7. Lavender

lavender

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: English Lavender, French Lavender, Lavadin

Why Grow Lavender in New York?

french lavender

Loves heat:

  • These low-maintenance herbs love the heat. The hotter the summer the better they do. And the longer summer goes on the more lavender you will have.

Perfect Ornamental Plant:

  • Lavender can also be considered an ornamental plant that is perfect for lawns, edges, garden containers, and traditional gardens. This means it can add color, features, and beauty to any type of yard.

Fits in ALL Gardens:

  • Regardless of whether you live in northern or southern New York lavender grows great in all types of gardens. I especially love growing them in raised garden beds and garden containers.

Insect Hardy:

  • If you have trouble with insects infecting your herbs in New York then you should plant lavender. This herb is one of the few in New York that you won’t have to worry about insect infestation all year.

THESE Could Harm Your Lavender

Cold

  • When the weather turns cold then your lavender won’t die, but it will stop growing, lose its fragrance, and won’t be ready to harvest until it grows back the following year.

Additional Resources

Learn How to Grow Lavender HERE


#8. Chamomile

growing chamomile

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: German & Roman

Why Grow Green Chamomile in New York?

German Chamomile

Thrives in Droughts:

  • Chamomile is another great herb that requires little to no additional watering than what it will get from rain. This makes it the perfect herb to grow in New York.

Perennial:

  • One of the greatest benefits of growing chamomile is that it is a perennial plant. This means you plant it once and you can enjoy it every year! I recommend planting & growing chamomile anywhere in your yard!

THESE Could Harm Your Chamomile

Garden Pests:

  • Rabbits, Deer, & even birds love eating chamomile. They’ll eat you’ll leave and even your flower buds if you do not protect them with netting or rodent spray.

Cold Weather:

  • Like most perennial herbs, chamomile will begin dying off once frost touches it. This means you can only grow this herb in late spring to early autumn.

Additional Resources

Learn How to Grow Chamomile HERE


#9. Garlic

Garlic Growing

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: Solo, Snow Mountain, Aglio

Why Grow Garlic in New York?

Garlic Growing 2

Thrives in Droughts:

  • Garlic is one of the few herbs that can thrive in droughts and extreme heat. It requires little water, no care, and no fertilizer.

Cold Weather:

  • Because Garlic is a perennial herb it can survive some of the most extreme temperatures compared to other herbs! You’ll notice it begins to grow in early spring and can survive all the way until late fall.

THESE Could Harm Your Garlic

Garden Pests:

  • Rabbits, Deer, & even birds can dig up and destroy your garlic. Most people think animals and pests will not eat pests, but that is a common myth. Protect your garlic with netting or rodent spray.

Additional Resources

The biggest tip I have when growing Garlic in New York is to place your herb in a space where you want it to grow every single year without having to move it. Most gardeners plant their herbs too close together or in an area that they decide later they want to grow other plants.


#10. Dill

superdukat dill

View Price of Seeds

Popular Varieties: Bouquet, Dukat, Fernleaf

Why Grow Dill in New York?

growing dill

Loves heat:

  • As you can tell there is a trend. Dill is another herb that does great in New York’s summer heat. The hotter, the better. But be careful, this means it could flower quicker and sour its flavor.

Numerous Varieties:

  • This may be one of the most underrated factors for growing dill in New York. There are almost 4 main types of dill, all of which have a unique taste. This means you can pick your type for your specific need and climate.

THESE Could Harm Your Dill

Beetles:

Beetles are annoying and destroy many plants, including herbs. While they typically eat leaves of trees they also can infest dill leaves and stalks and kill this herb in less than a day. To help prevent this I recommend using netting.

Additional Resources

Learn How to Grow Dill HERE


Common Growing Factors of New York’s Best Herbs

growing sage indoors

As a reminder, the below factors are common for the Best Herbs to Grow in New York:

  • Thrives in Heat & Drought
  • Thrives in Cold
  • Can Grow anywhere in your yard
  • Hardy against Pests & Insects
  • Can be planted in ALL Types of Garden
  • Great Cross-Pollinator
  • Are Perennial Plants

About the author